Why the hell should I trek all the way out to Queens? Answers within.

Wednesday, January 17, 2007

Malagueta vs. Manhattan


I'm not much of one to rabble-rouse, but all the Manhattan-centric
ideals that permeate New York living get a bit old. I understand their origin. I moved to New York City and that's where I intended to make
it. Then, I moved to Queens and I said, nope, this is where I'm going
to make it. I fit here. (I'm on a bit of free-floating diatribe,
forgive me. I gave up booze seven months ago after an incident at The Courtyard on Queens Blvd. - and I took the
treatment option. I know when to say when. Anyway. After the booze, I'm now strictly on
the Ambien. It's pretty harmless, some late night domain name
purchases, overbidding on ebay on occasion, nudity (mine). But, when I
post on the stuff, it gets difficult to maintain my focus and grammar.)

Anyway, Claire and I went to a Brazilian restaurant for our New Year's
Eve celebration in the Queens. While we were away for Christmas in
Montreal, we bought a subscription- full-on - from zagat.com. So, I
used that to find a restaurant. It suggested 'Malagueta'. It said
things like
A "refreshing surprise" in Astoria, a "well-rounded" lineup of
"excellent", "authentic" Brazilian dishes etc.

Now, here's what happened with that posting and how it got so far away
from the truth. People from Manhattan made the trip out to Astoria,
found a 'cute' restaurant run by amenable folk from the home country
and they thought it was just the greatest thing. They could run back
to Manhattan and tell their friends, pals and colleagues all about it.
"It was an adventure", "some of them know how to really cook", and so
on. Until more of them come. And they write the reviews, send them to
zagat. Tim, Nina and some other putz ex-copywriter do what they can
with it.

Here's the truth about the place - Malagueta is nice. The people who run
the place couldn't be nicer - for Brazilians- and if you know what I
mean great. If you don't, it's not an insult. Brazilians don't make a
big deal out of serving people. It's a job, it's done and it's done
well. They bring the stuff, tell you what it is and that's that.

Manhattanites come over, eat here, think it's quaint and that's what
ends up in Zagat.

We're from Queens. We ate there, we know there's better food to be had
and that's it. The sausage with yuca fries was tepid and over-cooked.
The fish Claire had was drowning in sauce and cheese and salt. My pork
loin didn't have enough sauce to bring it back to life from it's
terrible death in a hot searing pan. We're from Queens, we know
there's five other restaurants doing a better job within three blocks.

It's not the death of Malagueta. If they read this, they'll
understand, they'll fix it. We'll go back next year, we'll eat,
that'll be that.

Send us a list of your favorite restaurants in Western Queens. Don't
say Donovan's. Donovan's is the best restaurant on the planet. I hear
there's a bakery on Greenpoint that has special doughnuts on
Sundays...it's not in Zagats, but it'll be up here soon, I hope.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

Some people eat while on ambien, others write about eating while on ambien... :)

My recommendation is sapori d'ischia in Woodside, for the opera night and people watching factors alone!

Wesley Dumont said...

Malagueta scored a 24 on it's most recent inspection. Not bad. Especially for Astoria.

Anonymous said...

Hi Wesley,

Just to confirm, Malagueta scored a 27 for food in the Zagat Survey's 2007 NYC Restaurants guide. You'll notice that it has a downward triangle next to this score, indicating low votes were given for the restaurant.

In any event, please let us know what bakery you are talking about. It wouldn't be in our NYC Restaurants guide, but it might be in our 2007 NYC Marketplace guide. If you feel that it should be included in our guide, or if you would like to comment on Malagueta, please go to Zagat.com and submit your review and/or ratings.

Thank you,

Michael Mahle
Manager, Corporate Communications
Zagat Survey

Wesley Dumont said...

I'm sorry, the 24 I'm referring to is the score from the Health Dept. inspection.

I've noticed that MOST of the restaurants I frequent in Queens (and all over NYC) have serious problems with cleanliness.

After visiting LA - briefly - I noted how much cleaner all of their restaurants were - in all ways. Then I noticed that their health inspection ratings were posted in a huge letter-grade poster on the front door.

This started me checking out the lists of inspections on nyc.gov. Man, do we suck at cleanliness in our restaurants.

In fact, it's so bad that the Health Inspectors recently changed the grading reporting method. It used to be 'out of 100' with '100' being perfect. Points were deducted until a restaurant reached a failing grade.

Now - violation points are tallied - so, for example, Malagueta recieved 24 violation points. But, the scale is no longer 100 but, get this, 128 ???

So, rather than make it more transparent and useful, they've allowed the food lobby to influence their reporting methods to make them confusing and near-useless.

I encourage you to check out your favorite restaurants at nyc.gov

Oh, and one final comment - this from a Health Inspector's mouth - "Never, ever eat at a Chinese restaurant in New York City."